Is Your Network Actually Open? What more than 118,000 patient access calls reveal about physician availability

Health systems have developed careful methods for assessing physician availability. They audit their directories. They query their practice management systems. They ask their physicians directly. In nearly every case, the answer they receive is more optimistic than the one their patients experience.

3Dhealth’s national outbound call dataset now covers more than 118,000 calls to physician practices, across 42 states and 16 years so far.  It tests that gap directly. Not through self-reported data, and not through scheduling software. Through the same channel patients use: the phone.

The Difference Between Listed and Available

A physician directory or roster reflects licensure, credentialing, and specialty affiliation. What it rarely reflects is whether that physician is actually accepting new patients today, or has been for months.

Across the dataset, roughly one in seven physicians was not accepting new patients at all. Another 3.7% were selectively open, meaning access was conditional, often on payer type, referral source, or criteria that appear in no directory. Others reached voicemail with no opportunity to schedule, or left the caller on hold longer than five minutes before the conversation could begin.

These are not edge cases. They are what patients encounter at scale, and they describe a network that can appear open on a roster and be substantially closed when a patient calls.

1 in 7 of all physicians are not accepting new patients.
Only 6.6% of closed panels offered an alternative.

The Front Door Is Closed a Quarter of the Time

Primary care used to run on a simple model. A physician built a panel, filled it, and closed it. That made sense when the physician owned the practice and the panel was the business.

Health systems changed the arrangement. Employing primary care physicians means owning the front door, and a front door is meant to stay open. Primary care is where patients enter the system, where referrals originate, and where the relationship that shapes everything downstream begins.

The data show the old behavior persisting inside the new arrangement.

Primary care practices show an open rate of 72.1% and a closed rate of 24.1%. Specialists show an open rate of 90.0% and a closed rate of 6.8%. A specialty practice turns over, so a specialist has to keep taking new patients to stay full. Primary care has never worked that way.

Employment does not appear to change it. Employed primary care physicians are closed 24.2% of the time. Aligned physicians close at 24.0%. Non-aligned physicians close at 30.4%, which means the gap between an employed base and an independent one is narrower than most health systems would assume.

A health system that employs its primary care base and assumes that base is open to patients is describing an intention rather than a measurement.

“The front door of most health systems is primary care. If that door is closed a quarter of the time, the rest of the network does not matter to that patient.” –Ron Flower, President & CEO, 3Dhealth

Even Open Panels Create Barriers

Accepting new patients is a necessary condition for access, not a sufficient one.

Across specialties, the current national average wait for a new patient appointment is 34 days, with a median of 26. The range underneath those figures is wide. Podiatry averages 13 days and sports medicine 14. Dermatology averages 47 and endocrinology 46. Several pediatric subspecialties run past 90 days, and pediatric rehabilitation medicine averages more than 150.

In each of those cases the panel is technically open. Access, as a patient would define it, is still weeks or months away.

This is why self-reported assessments fail. Asked whether they are accepting new patients, a physician or practice manager answers based on whether the panel is theoretically open. They are not reporting that the next available appointment is two months out. That is the reality a patient encounters.

When the Answer Is No, Patients Are Rarely Given a Path

The most consequential finding may not be how often physicians are closed. It is what happens when they are.

Where a caller could not be accommodated and an alternative was possible, an advanced practice provider, a partner location, another physician, one was offered 6.6% of the time. In the other 93.4% of those calls, no alternative was provided.

That is not a staffing problem. Health systems invest in advanced practice providers, co-located specialties, and new patient programs, and then find those options are never surfaced when access breaks down on the phone. The infrastructure exists. The protocol to activate it does not.

For a patient who has just been told a physician is not accepting new patients, the conversation does not need to end there. Without scripting, staff authority, and a defined escalation path, it does, more than nine times out of ten.

What This Means for Access Strategy

Three patterns hold across sixteen years of data.

Directory accuracy is a lagging indicator. Availability changes continuously as panel preferences, payer mix, and practice circumstances shift. A directory reflects what was true at its last update. An outbound call reflects what is true today.

Primary care closure is underweighted. Most health systems track specialist referral wait times and recruitment pipelines closely. Far fewer have equivalent visibility into primary care panel closures, which occur several times more often and cannot be scheduled around.

The missing alternative is a system failure, not an individual one. When more than nine in ten callers who reach a closed panel are given no path forward, that is design rather than training.

Measuring Access Where Patients Encounter It

3Dhealth’s outbound call methodology tests the access experience as patients meet it, rather than as a system reports it or a physician perceives it. Over sixteen years the dataset has become the basis for how we assess network adequacy, evaluate panel performance, and find access gaps that conventional planning tools do not reach.

You cannot fix what you have not measured. For most health systems, the true state of their network has never been tested at the point where patients encounter it.

Learn more about→ Patient Access Studies 

For questions or more information, please contact Ron Flower at RFlower@3Dhealthinc.com or 312-423-2673.

To schedule an appointment with Ron, please contact Annalisa Reese at AReese@3Dhealthinc.com.